The anti-China bias and why Thucydides trap is just an invention (and a
dangerous one)
Abstract
Allison’s Thucydides trap has become one of the most potent analogies
used to describe US-Chinese relations. It can be found everywhere among
political observers and policymakers. While the notion has met several
criticisms, to date no one has observed that Allison relied on an
inaccurate adaptation of the English translation of Thucydides’ key
sentence he used. This inaccuracy has led to the invention of Thucydides
trap, whereby a rising power, Athens (China), threatens a hegemonic
power, Sparta (the US): and this threat often results in war. Yet
Thucydides’ key sentence, the rest of his work, and (even basic)
familiarity with Greek history point to the fact that the two rivals
were already established hegemonic powers. There was no rise of Athens,
but Sparta’s fear that the Athenian empire may take over all of Greece.
This article shows how abuses of Thucydides in the form of Thucydides
trap serve US attempts to legitimize its presence in East Asia while
feeding into Western Sinophobia.