Advance
Preprints are early versions of research articles that have not been peer reviewed. They should not be regarded as conclusive and should not be reported in news media as established information.
Rationing during pandemics - Laar et al preprint.pdf (241.89 kB)

Rationing health and social goods during pandemics: guidance for Ghanaian decision makers

Download (241.89 kB)
preprint
posted on 29.07.2020 by Amos Laar, Debra DeBruin, Richard Ofori-Asenso, Matilda Essandoh Laar, Barbara Redman, Arthur Caplan

Abstract

Healthcare rationing during pandemics has been widely discussed in global bioethics literature. However, existing scenarios and analyses have focused on high income countries, except for very few disease areas such as HIV treatment where some analyses related to African countries exist. We argue that the lack of scholastic discourse, and by extension, professional and democratic engagement on the subject constitute an unacceptable ethical omission. Not only have African governments failed to develop robust ethical plans for pandemics, ethicists in this region have been unable to ignite public discourse on rationing. Therefore, we aim to initiate a debate on how rationing health and social goods could be done ethically in Ghana during the current and future pandemics.

The paper discusses and critiques some moral considerations (utilitarian, equity, equal worth, urgent need, and the prioritarian principles) for rationing and their relevance in the Ghanaian context. This contribution may facilitate ethical decision-making during COVID-19 in Ghana and other African settings where hardly any rationing guidelines exist


Funding

Not Funded

History

Declaration of conflicts of interest

None Declared

Corresponding author email

alaar@ug.edu.gh

Lead author country

Ghana

Lead author job role

Higher Education Lecturer

Lead author institution

University of Ghana

Human Participants

No

Ethics statement

No human subjects involved

Licence

Exports

Comments

Log in to write your comment here...
Logo branding

Categories

Licence

Exports