Advance
Preprints are early versions of research articles that have not been peer reviewed. They should not be regarded as conclusive and should not be reported in news media as established information.
Media Culture Society - 13 Reasons Why v2.docx (51.25 kB)
0/0

13 Reasons Why: Can a TV Show About Suicide Be 'Dangerous?’ What is the Responsibility of a Producer?

Download (51.25 kB)
preprint
posted on 10.05.2019 by Marco Scalvini

The release of the Netflix’s show 13 Reasons Whycaused significant public concern about the risk of suicide contagion among teenagers – particularly those who have suicidal thoughts. Practitioners and researchers expressed apprehension about the show for its apparent praise of suicide and for allegedly increasing suicide risk among vulnerable teenagers. However, there is a lack of clear evidence for the influence of fictional content on self-harm. Little is known about variations in media effects between news and fiction. The literature focuses mainly on non-fictional media reporting, without making any distinction between individual vulnerability and the type of media portrayal. The present article criticises the assumption that risk of self-harm is reduced by sanitising fictional content. The absence of scientific evidence is precisely why this article re-addresses the problem through an ethical perspective by focusing on the moral responsibility of Netflix in creating graphic content for young adults. Censoring fiction may do more harm than good, but producers have the responsibility to evaluate in advance the potential impact that such content has on vulnerable people and support viewers as well as parents, educators, practitioners through an adequate campaign of prevention.

History

Declaration of conflicts of interest

The author declares no conflicts of interest

Corresponding author email

marco.scalvini@nyu.edu

Lead author country

Netherlands

Lead author job role

Higher Education Lecturer

Lead author institution

Erasmus University, Rotterdam

Human Participants

No

Licence

Exports

Comments

Log in to write your comment here...